How To Get Homeowners Insurance After Non-Renewal

How To Get Homeowners Insurance After Non-Renewal – A few months before your homeowner’s insurance policy’s end date, your insurance company will send you a notice. Typically, homeowners insurance companies send renewal notices to their policyholders to continue their coverage. However, there are instances where they send nonrenewal notices instead.

How To Get Homeowners Insurance After Non-Renewal

If you get a notice of nonrenewal, your insurer will explain why it’s opting not to renew your policy. Occasionally, the issue can be resolved and presented to your insurer for reconsideration of renewal. However, in some instances, receiving a nonrenewal notice indicates that you’ll have to begin searching for a new homeowner’s insurance provider to prevent a coverage gap. In this article, we will outline how to get homeowners insurance after non-renewal.

Reasons for Homeowners Insurance Nonrenewal

Upon deciding not to renew a homeowner’s insurance policy, insurers are obligated to provide a written explanation to the policyholder, outlining the rationale behind their decision. Some of the most prevalent factors that may lead to the nonrenewal of a homeowner’s insurance policy are as follows:

High-risk areas:

Insurance providers may opt to discontinue coverage in certain locations due to a heightened risk of losses. Such as during the recent California wildfires, which prompted a one-year moratorium on nonrenewal by the California Insurance Commissioner.

Homeowner History:

Carriers may decline to renew policies based on the policyholder’s history. This includes multiple or costly claims, late payments, or changes in circumstances.

 Personal Factors:

Meanwhile, Insurers may also consider personal factors such as a decline in credit score. The acquisition of a new dog breed that is restricted by the company, or the presence of attractive nuisances like pools or playground equipment.


Standard home insurance policies often contain vacancy clauses, which allow the insurer to cancel. Or non-renew the policy if the home is unoccupied for a specified period, typically 30 days or more.

Home maintenance:

Insurers may conduct exterior inspections of the property to ensure that it is well-maintained and free from safety hazards. Failure to maintain the property may result in nonrenewal.

Discontinuation of underwriting:

On rare occasions, an insurance provider may decide to cease operations in a particular area or discontinue selling a specific type of homeowners’ insurance policy. This necessitates the policyholder to find an alternative insurer. This situation is currently prevalent in Florida’s homeowners’ insurance crisis, where many carriers are voluntarily leaving the state or restricting policy eligibility requirements.

How To Get Homeowners Insurance After Non-Renewal

Following a nonrenewal notice, it is essential to explore various options to secure coverage for your home. Here are some steps to consider:

Address the issue:

 If the nonrenewal is due to unaddressed concerns, such as home maintenance. This promptly addressing them may encourage the insurer to reconsider the nonrenewal. Providing evidence of resolution may support your case.

Challenge the nonrenewal:

If you believe the nonrenewal reason is unjust, you can contest it by contacting the insurance provider’s consumer affairs division or your state’s insurance department.

Seek a new policy:

Allowing your current policy to lapse can result in a lack of coverage and potentially higher future rates. Also, if you have a mortgage, maintaining continuous coverage is typically a loan condition. Failure to ensure home coverage may result in your lender obtaining force-placed insurance, often at a higher cost.

Schedule the effective date:

When purchasing a new policy, ensure the effective date aligns with or precedes the last day of your current coverage to prevent a lapse. Notify your lender of the changes.

Consider high-risk insurance:

If your home is classified as high-risk, obtaining high-risk home insurance can provide the necessary coverage, albeit potentially at a higher cost than a standard policy.

Utilize your state’s FAIR plan:

Some states offer a FAIR plan, or Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plan, which provides insurance coverage for homes that do not qualify for private market coverage. This government insurance program is designed to ensure access to insurance for all homeowners.

What happens if I am unable to secure a new policy following a nonrenewal?

Although home insurance is not a legal requirement, if you have a mortgage, your lender will mandate that you maintain a home insurance policy. If you are unable to find a new policy independently, your lender will arrange for one on your behalf. This arrangement is commonly referred to as force-placed insurance or lender-placed insurance. These policies generally offer reduced coverage compared to standard homeowners’ insurance policies and frequently come at a higher cost.


What should I do if my homeowners’ insurance policy is not renewed?

If your homeowner’s insurance policy is not renewed, you should first try to contest the decision if you believe it was unjustified. If that fails, you can use an insurance marketplace to research the best policies and apply for a new one online. Additionally, you can consider buying into your state’s FAIR Plan, a high-risk insurance pool administered by the state’s Department of Insurance and funded by private companies.

How can I prove that my house isn’t as risky as the insurer thinks it is?

To prove that your house isn’t as risky as the insurer thinks, you can provide evidence that you’ve mitigated your risk exposure. For example, you can show that you’ve replaced the roof or performed other upgrades that lower the risk of damage or loss.

You can also demonstrate that your state has a lot of variation in climate risks within a small geographical area, so the risk exposure varies from block to block.

What are the limitations of FAIR plans?

Fair plans have strict limits that you won’t find with private plans. For example, they typically don’t have liability protection or additional coverage for valuables, and personal property is usually only covered at its actual cash value. Additionally, they may require you to prove that you’ve been turned down by at least three insurance companies before you can get approved.